A few years back, I remember tirelessly tracking down “Sunsets and Car Crashes” by The Spill Canvas, a little-known album by a little-known singer. Fast-forward to over three years later, and The Spill Canvas has officially hit the big time.
Originally starting out as a solo project, Nick Thomas recorded his first album, “Sunsets and Car Crashes,” and gained an underground fan base.
After catching the eye of One Eleven Records, Thomas formed a full-on band, with Dan Ludeman on guitar, Landon Heil on bass and Joe Beck covering the drums. After releasing the debut album “One Fell Swoop,” The Spill Canvas signed to Sire Records, where in 2007, the band released “No Really, I’m Fine.”
Of all of the CDs I’ve ever listened to, I have to say that “No Really, I’m Fine” has one of the strongest openings.
While listening to the song “Reckless Abandonment,” I had to chuckle at lyrics about how the band doesn’t care “that these critics/they’re writing in their magazines.” Instead of a typical song about long-lost love, The Spill Canvas manages to confront its change in music styling head-on.
Once “All Over You” hit the airways (courtesy of FM97), I was convinced I had to buy the album. It mixes pop and rock perfectly, with a catchy chorus and smart lyrics. Whenever I hear the song, whether in my car or my room, I can’t help but belt out the tune and dance around (much to my sister’s dismay).
Although a great song, just like “Reckless Abandonment,” it has a much different feel.
The third song, “Battles,” is reminiscent of some of The Spill Canvas’ earlier work on “One Fell Swoop.” That, however, is one of the only songs that has a similar sound to older works. None of the songs on the album sounds at all similar to “Sunsets and Car Crashes,” which isn’t necessarily bad, just different.
While other bands are classified as pop, punk, emo or alternative, The Spill Canvas manages to present a different kind of unclassified rock. None of the songs on the album sounds like another, which keeps the listener’s interest.
At the beginning of the album, it seems like “No Really, I’m Fine” is destined to become one of those rare albums where I love every song. However, once the album hits the seventh song, “Low Fidelity,” it begins to go downhill. The song is good, but not nearly as great at its predecessor. In fact, the album peaks at the sixth song, “Hush Hush,” with it being by far one of the best songs on the album.
By the time “No Really, I’m Fine” reaches its 12th song, “Lullaby,” I feel disappointed that the album didn’t live up to my expectations. The song tries to rekindle Thomas’ acoustic roots, but with its overdramatic strings and lyrics, it’s hard to feel the passion felt in the earlier songs.
Overall, the first six songs on the album are well worth its cost. When offered the last six songs, though, you may have the urge to tell the band that no really, you’re fine.
